Staffing Services

Finding the right talent is crucial to your business’s success. With so many staffing options available, it can be difficult to know which one fits your specific needs. Whether you’re looking for temporary staffing to cover a short-term project, seeking a full-time hire to strengthen your team, or need payroll services to simplify your operations, understanding the differences between staffing options is key to making the best choice for your business.

In this guide, we’ll explore the four main types of staffing services—Temporary Staffing, Temp-to-Hire, Direct Hire, and Payroll Only—so you can make an informed decision based on your business’s unique needs. Learn how each staffing solution works, when it’s most beneficial, and why it could be the right fit for your company.

Staffing Services

Temporary Staffing

Temporary staffing is a flexible, cost-effective solution when you need workers for short-term projects, seasonal demands, or to cover employee absences. This service allows employers to fill immediate staffing needs without the lengthy hiring process or commitment to long-term employment. Temporary staffing is ideal for businesses looking for quick assistance with projects or to handle busy periods without the risk of overstaffing.

Forklift operator moving crates of apples in a warehouse, representing temporary staffing for warehouse roles.

When to use Temporary Staffing

Temporary staffing is perfect for situations where you need extra hands for a limited period. For example, if you’re dealing with a seasonal increase in demand, a project with a strict timeline, or an employee taking medical leave, temporary staff can help you maintain productivity without the complexity of hiring. It’s also useful for covering a gap between employees leaving and new hires arriving, allowing you to keep operations running smoothly in the interim.

Why Employers Choose Temporary Staffing Services

Employers often choose temporary staffing because it provides immediate access to a qualified workforce without long-term commitment. Temporary workers can start as soon as possible and quickly integrate into your team. This option is highly flexible, allowing you to adjust staffing levels as needed without the time-consuming recruitment process. Additionally, it’s a low-risk way to evaluate potential future employees without committing to a permanent hire, offering a chance to assess fit and performance on the job.

Diverse workers in blue coveralls and safety gear, representing temp-to-hire staffing for skilled roles.

Temp-to-Hire Staffing

Temp-to-hire staffing combines the flexibility of temporary staffing with the opportunity for permanent placement. This service allows you to evaluate a worker’s skills, performance, and cultural fit for a specific role over a trial period before offering them a permanent position. Temp-to-hire staffing is a great choice when you’re unsure about a candidate but want to ensure a good match before committing to a long-term hire.

When to use Temp-to-hire staffing

Temp-to-hire staffing is ideal when you’re looking to fill positions with candidates who have the potential for long-term employment but want to ensure they’re the right fit. If you’re uncertain about hiring someone directly but want to avoid the risk of a bad hire, this service gives you the flexibility to try out candidates for a set period (usually 3-6 months) to evaluate their performance, work ethic, and fit within your company culture.

Why Employers Choose Temp-to-Hire Staffing

Employers choose temp-to-hire staffing for its balance of flexibility and long-term potential. It provides a “try before you buy” option, allowing you to assess candidates’ skills and suitability for the role without making an immediate, permanent decision. It reduces the risk of hiring someone who may not be the right fit while giving the candidate time to demonstrate their abilities. Temp-to-hire staffing also saves you time in the hiring process since the candidate is already vetted and working on your team. It’s an excellent way to secure top talent without committing to a permanent hire right away.

Direct Hire Staffing

Direct hire staffing is the solution for employers seeking highly skilled professionals for long-term, permanent roles. In a direct hire arrangement, All StarZ handles the entire recruitment process, from sourcing to screening to presenting candidates for selection. This service is ideal for filling critical, full-time positions where stability and long-term career growth are important.

Business professionals shaking hands, representing direct hire staffing for long-term hires.

When to use Direct Hire staffing

Direct hire staffing is best when you need candidates who are focused on permanent, stable employment and who are highly skilled for key positions. This service is perfect for roles that require a specific skill set or experience and for employers who want to avoid the trial period associated with temp-to-hire staffing. Direct hire is ideal when you’re looking for high-quality candidates who can step in and contribute from day one, especially in positions where turnover is costly or difficult.

Why Employers Choose Direct Hire Staffing

Employers choose direct hire staffing when they want to attract top-tier candidates who are seeking long-term stability and career growth. This service provides access to a broader candidate pool, especially for roles where skills and experience are critical. While direct hire involves a commitment to hire the candidate immediately, it’s a smart choice for positions that require high-level talent and where the employer is looking for candidates who are committed to the organization for the long haul. Additionally, this approach saves employers the time and effort involved in handling recruiting, sourcing, and interviewing, leaving those tasks to All StarZ. By skipping the trial period, direct hire candidates are often more experienced and ready to contribute quickly to the business.

Close-up of a desk with a calculator, laptop, and data charts, representing payroll-only staffing services.

Payroll Only Services

Payroll-only staffing allows employers to manage the hiring process themselves while outsourcing the administrative responsibilities of payroll, taxes, and compliance. This service is designed for businesses that have already found candidates for specific roles but need help with managing their workforce’s payroll and compliance requirements.

When to use Payroll Only Services

Payroll-only services are ideal when you’ve already selected candidates but want to offload the time-consuming tasks of managing payroll and ensuring compliance with labor laws. It’s often used when companies want to handle the recruitment and hiring process in-house but need external help to manage wages, taxes, and other payroll functions. This service is especially useful for companies that need temporary or contract workers without the administrative burden of managing multiple workers’ payroll.

Why Employers Choose Payroll Only Services

Employers choose payroll-only services when they want to simplify their operations and focus on their core business activities. By outsourcing payroll and compliance to All StarZ, businesses can avoid the administrative hassle and risks associated with incorrect tax filings and employee misclassification. Payroll-only services are often more cost-effective than managing this in-house, and they ensure that workers are paid accurately and on time while staying compliant with all applicable regulations. This option is flexible and can be tailored to fit the needs of any business, providing the right amount of support to allow you to concentrate on other priorities.

Which Staffing Services Are Right For You?

  • Temporary Staffing
  • Popular
    Temp-to-Hire
  • Direct Hire
  • Payroll Only
Temporary Staffing
Popular
Temp-to-Hire
Direct HirePayroll Only
Per Unit Pricing
Hourly Pricing
Best ForFilling short-term or seasonal needs quicklyEvaluating candidates before long-term commitmentHiring top talent for long-term rolesManaging payroll for employees you've already sourced
Main BenefitFast & flexible coverage for short-term needsOpportunity to evaluate fit before hiring long-termAccess to highly skilled candidates for long-term rolesSimplifies payroll management for your chosen hires
Length of EmploymentShort-term, varies by project or seasonTrial period - terms defined in your contractLong-term: employee will be on your payroll from day oneFlexible - you decide!
Candidate PoolSkilled workers for short-term or seasonal rolesVersatile candidates open to long-term opportunitiesTop talent seeking stable, career-focused positionsCandidates you've sourced independently
Candidate SelectionCandidates are send-to-start, no interviews neededFlexible - interviewing depends on contract termsFull control - interview and select your ideal candidateComplete autonomy - you source and interview your own candidates
FlexibilityEasy to adjust staffing levels as needs changeEvaluate candidates during a trial period before hiringTrade flexibility for top-tier candidates who prefer stable, long-term roles over temp-to-hireYou define the role, set terms, and select candidates while we handle payroll and compliance
Request an AssociateBuy Now
Business team planning workforce agility strategies for 2025 at a modern office conference table. Overlay text reads: 'Is your workforce ready to thrive in 2025?'

4 Deadly Traps Just Waiting for You as a New HR Leader & How to Avoid Them!

Moving into a brand-new leadership role is the #1 challenge any HR professional can face…no matter how much HR experience you have! That’s a fact. Here are just four of the many common, but deadly traps that can bite you in the butt...

Of course you can ask about a resume gap – it’s not technically illegal – but the cons may outweigh the pros. Skip the risk: A staffing partner eliminates this sticky wicket for you – will only refer vetted, qualified candidates…